Beginnings
cheese curds poutine
$10.00
breaded wisconsin curds, demi-glace, shredded short ribs, beer cheese drizzlejalapeño popper dip
$8.00
cream cheese, cheddar & mozzarella, roasted hot peppers, bacon, green onion, warm bavarian pretzelsbreaded mozzarella
$9.00
hand cut & fried wedges, house marinara, crispy parsleyfried calamari & olives
$12.00
lightly fried, crispy capers, house cured olives, lemonclassic shrimp cocktail
$13.00
poached white shrimp, classic cocktail sauce or coconut curry dipping saucepork belly & pickles board
$11.00
sweet & spicy chili glazed pork belly slabs, house made pickled onions & cucumbers, cinnamon chipotle chipswings
$9.00
always at the pony... bone-in or tenders choose: classic buffalo, hot honey, bbq or jala-mango served with bleu cheese, ranch or honey mustardeverything spiced ahi tuna
$13.00
seared & chilled, thin sliced, chili aioli, avocado, shaved scallionlittleneck clams
$13.00
drawn butter or beer broth, fresh lemon, crostiniSalads
add grilled chicken 4 | add seared salmon 8 add filet medallions 8* | add shrimp 6garden
$8.00
cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, olives, peppers, shredded carrots, field greens, house croutonsharvest
$9.00
sweetened cranberries, glazed pecans, bosc pears, gorgonzola cheese, harvest greenscobb
$11.00
avocado, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese, pork belly lardons, tomatoes, chopped greensGreek
$9.00
local feta, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, kalamata olives, chopped romaineFlat Breads
fig, onions, pork belly & gorgonzola
$14.00
mission fig jam, caramelized onions, pork belly lardonsShort ribs, green onions & asiago
$14.00
braised & shredded short ribs, tomato, beer cheese drizzleBuild your own
$9.00
red sauce or fig jam, mozzarella or cheddar 9 | add chicken 2, short ribs 3, pork belly 3, feta 2, gorgonzola 2, fresh mozzarella 2, spinach 1, peppers 1, onions 1, tomatoes 1, mushrooms 1, olives 1roasted tomato & artichoke
$14.00
garlic oil, mozzarella blend, basil pestokalamata, feta & spinach
$13.00
alfredo, tomato, lemon peel, red onionHands
served with house slaw, fries or side saladburger
$12.00
8oz house choice blend, pickled onions, lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, brioche bun bacon, caramelized onions, avocadobistro burger
$14.00
8oz choice blend, caramelized onions, gorgonzola cheese, fig jam, brioche bunjala-mango burger
$14.00
8oz choice blend, cheddar cheese, jala-mango glazed onion rings, pork belly, brioche bunpork belly
$13.00
hot honey, pickles, house slaw, smashed curds, cajun crema, brioche bunchicken & waffles
$13.00
buttermilk fried chicken breast, roasted jalapeno jam, heirloom tomato salata, cheddar cheese & green onion Belgian waffle, smoked chili aiolisteak & cheese
$13.00
cheddar, caramelized onions, shaven prime rib, bourbon demi-glace for dippingchicken avocado
$12.00
marinated & grilled breast, smoked bacon, tomatoes, avocado, lemon ailoi | add cheese 1chicken parm
$10.00
hand breaded chicken breast, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, tuscan rolleggplant parm
$9.00
hand breaded eggplant, melted mozzarella, house tomato sauce, tuscan rollfresh pasta
(choose tagliatelle or bucatini) | sub gluten free 2 served with garden salad & garlic breadclassic pasta dishes
choose pasta, choose sauce: marinara 14 | alfredo, pesto, vodka sauce 15 | add meatballs 5 | add chicken 5 | add shrimp 7pasta putanesca
$18.00
classic tomato & caper sauce, mixed olives, garlic, roasted peppers & artichoke heartspasta e carbonara
$18.00
creamy alfredo, bacon, peas & parmesanbolognese
$18.00
traditional slow-cooked beef, pork & tomatoes, parmesan cheese, fresh herbswhite clam sauce
$22.00
fresh littlenecks, garlic, white wine broth, virgin oil, parsleyseafood arribiata
$24.00
calamari, shrimp, scallops, clams, spicy garlic & tomato sauce, toasted fennel, parmesan cheesewild mushroom ravioli & short ribs
$24.00
porcini mushrooms, shredded braised short ribs, veal demi-glace, light cream, parmesan cheese, fresh herbsMains
pan seared scallops
$24.00
pan seared, cracked pepper, white wine, butter & lemon sauce, crispy brussels sprouts, pork bellynorwegian salmon fillet
$24.00
brown sugar & sea salt glaze, sauteed spinach, cauliflower risottofish & chips
$17.00
golden ale battered haddock, potatoes, tarter sauce, house slawtuna livernese
$28.00
black & blue seared tuna, peppercorn crust, garlic, tomato, capers, olives, tagliatelle pastamac & cheese
$12.00
cheddar gouda blend, shell pasta add short ribs 8, add pork belly 6rosemary chicken
$18.00
parmesan crusted chicken breast, herbed compound butter, shaved brussels, cauliflower risottoSteaks & Chop
with two sides. add 2.00 for gorgonzola butter | whiskey demi-glace wild mushrooms | peppadew peppers caramelized onions | roasted garlicprime rib ...always at the pony
$19.00
10oz | 16oz | 22oz au jus, horseradish creamnew york strip
$26.00
12oz boneless striploin, gorgonzola buttertenderloin medallions
$28.00
sauteed mushrooms, whiskey demi-glacebraised short ribs
$26.00
10oz, veal demi-glacepork rib chop
$24.00
duroc pork, brown sugar & sea salt, poached pear chutneysteak tips
$24.00
bourbon & brown sugar marinated, pan seared, caramelized onions, mushrooms & peppersdelmonico
$26.00
14oz off-the-bone ribeye, garlic butterPony Classics
choice of soup or saladchicken parmigiana
$19.00
breaded chicken breast fillets, mozzarella, tomato sauce, capellinichicken alexander
$19.00
breaded chicken breast, white Wine, mushrooms, mozzarellachicken caruso
$22.00
breaded chicken breast, shrimp, broccoli, Newburgh saucechicken picata
$19.00
egg-dipped chicken breast, butter wine sauce, capers, fresh lemon, choice of pastanew england baked cod
$20.00
cracker crumbs, white wine & butter roasted cod, choose two sideseggplant parmigiana
$18.00
breaded chicken breast fillets, mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh herbs, choice of pastaSides
house fries
$4.00
onion rings
$6.00
soup otd
$5.00
spinach
$5.00
mashed pots
$5.00
sweet tots
$5.00
tossed salad
$5.00
avgolemeno soup
$5.00
roasted potatoes
$5.00
roasted carrots
$5.00
cauliflower risotto
$5.00
house slaw
$5.00
- 203-266-5771
- Bethlehem
Bethlehem
203-266-5771 •74 Main St. S.
74 Main St. S.
Bethlehem, CT 06751
203-266-5771
We Are Currently
